Anyone's here?
The dead person is Zhen Baoxian,
a tenant of an apartment in Beverly.
The sister was diagnosed with a malignant brain tumor.
The cost for surgery is one million yuan.
Do you know Zhen Baoxian threatened you?
I'll protect you.
I'll make him shut his mouth forever.
My hands are covered in blood.
I have to protect my brother.
Ou Maiga told Zhen Baoxian
that He Daoba is a serial murderer.
Did you murder anyone?
I found out that Zhen Baoxian was investigating me.
This is my motive for killing Zhen Baoxian.
Your brother Jia Erer
died suddenly.
It couldn't have been accidental.
Found the person dead in the hole
and pretending to be second brother.
I poured axit sulfuric.
You destroyed his face?
Deceitful.
Second brother,
he actually arrived.
Do you know he's threatening your younger brother?
Who is she?
She just keeps provoking conflicts
between Zhen Baoxian and He Daoba.
You want to set the trap for him to be caught in?
What's your evidence?
I totally have no idea
about Ou Maiga's motive.
But now,
where is the second brother?
With the current evidence, I have to say that
I suspect him most,
and then Ou Maiga.
Because I think her story's not clear.
Right.
So I'll vote for these two people.
Now I'm more leaning towards Jia Dasa.
Come on.
I'm sorry.
Now let's look for the evidence.
Sure, let's do it.
There's a dead-end detective above.
Arrange, arrange, arrange the flower basket.
Arrange, arrange the flower basket
Today we meet a dead-end detective.
Stop.
There's a dead-end detective above today.
Body search.
Let's me have a body search.
Where?
Can you be more gentle?
Why you keep being so violent?
Mobile phone.
You're surfing the phone.
Bai Jingting
Coach Dasa
it's hard for you to rush
to my hotel in half an hour this morning.
It was this morning.
You had to go our at six this morning right?
Before six.
Your today's position has improved a lot.
Position?
Right.
Basketball. I taught him to play basketball.
Throw the ball.
It means you went to his hotel at six,
right?
No, we finished at six.
Finished teaching?
Finished teaching.
I said
his today's position had improved a lot.
So you came back at half past six?
And then you went to have breakfast at seven?
So between half past six and seven,
you had a secret time period.
Right.
You called him yesterday?
What did you talk about in two minutes?
What does Hu Ru mean?
Say something.
I'm sorry.
At 5:10 PM yesterday.
What did you tell him?
I just said I knew
that the body wasn't Jia Erer's.
If I tell this to the insurance company,
we can't get the money, not to mention when the police know
you guys can be sent to jail.
What did he want from you?
He said if I agreed with him something,
I would
never mention this again.
Something?
What's it?
Agreeing to eliminate
a person who looks aggressive but reserved.
I got that call, too.
I got that, too.
Eliminate him for me.
Zhen asked you to kill him,
to kill He?
He found two photos.
I didn't do it.
Who knows? Zhen didn't know either.
He called us
telling the same thing.
He told us,
he knew the dead person
wasn't Jia Erer
but a different one.
Then he said if we told the insurance company about it,
it meant
we couldn't get even a penny.
He said
if I wanted him not to tell the insurance company
there was a way.
He gave me a condition,
that was to eliminate the guy for him.
He also asked my big brother
to help eliminate him.
But he told both of you
the same thing.
It means that he did put
the complete murdering plan
onto that oven.
Right.
Besides, he told us
that murdering plan
was given to him by others.
However...
How many people want to kill me?
He gets scared stiff right away.
I can't move my legs,
nearly falling down onto the floor.
He said that when I finished reading it
I had to burn it out.
But I hesitated to take the plan
because I didn't want to kill him.
I wanted...
but I wanted to kill him.
You didn't want to kill him
but you want to eliminate Zhen Baoxian.
Because Zhen Baoxian knew about it.
He was threatening you.
I was afraid that if I helped him eliminate He,
he would still use it to threaten me.
Therefore, I want to eliminate him,
but I couldn't
use this plan
to kill Zhen Baoxian.
Because Zhen Baoxian had known about the plan
so I didn't take it.
So where is the plan?
I saw it was written
"Your thing has been delivered."
The thing burnt at seven in the morning
was actually the plan.
So your big brother took the plan.
Are two of us the persons suspected?
Who is the murder in two of you?
Someone gave the plan to Zhen Baoxian.
Right?
Did you see the plan?
I'm like him.
The reasons are also similar.
I wanted to eliminate Zhen
because I thought
if that time Zhen asked me to kill him
he would certainly force me to threaten others next time.
The motive for murdering of both of you
can't have been the same.
Don't act anymore. Arranging the flower basket?
I put the flower basket in her house.
What other flower basket did I arrange?
No, do you need to have a body search first?
Have a body search.
No.
You must have a body search first.
Body search.
We need to have a body search.
Are you ready?
I'm ready. You can check now.
Have a check.
Touch.
Let me.
VIP isn't important.
VIP says he's going on a business trip
can you quickly
bring the shoes polished yesterday.
Okay, I'll bring now.
Early in the morning.
Half past six.
She was delivering the shoes.
It means that at seven this morning
we all went out for a walk.
Everyone went out.
Everyone had something to handle before seven.
Do you have anything with you now?
I have nothing.
Ms. Ou, can you walk two steps?
Wait, here.
Take it.
I'll take it.
Get the key to open it.
Quick, quick.
Hurry up.
It can be finally unlocked.
Guigui will unlock it.
I don't know where it is.
I don't know which key.
And where to open.
Look around Ou's room.
You can give us some hints.
We all don't know what to do next.
Take it out. There it is. Take it out.
I took it out.
Open it.
You can do it.
You opened it now.
Am I great?
You're really great.
Is there anyone saying this?
Another mobile phone.
And a piece of newspaper.
What should we read?
This one.
Premier news
The Physics valedictorian of M city's university entrance examination has appeared
Ou Xiaodi.
My dream is not to change the world,
but to make the world a better place.
So distinguished.
2006's university entrance examination achievements
are officially announced.
The valedictorian of M city's university entrance examination receives widespread attention.
Attention?
Widespread attention?
The Physics valedictorian is unexpectedly
Ou Xiaodi in M city.
When he got interview from the reporter
he was shy saying that
he had no special recipe for success, just because of his passion for study.
Talking about his future plan,
he said he would try his best
to protect the environment
to make the world a better place.
The words in red are the most important thing.
"I'm sure I don't let your death pointless."
Little brother, the season is recently changing,
it's getting colder,
remember to put your coat on,
don't make yourself catch a flu.
Sister,
I have to go back the dorm,
I'm not waiting for you.
I'll take a short cut
through the back flower garden to return to school.
Don't work too hard.
I am going to graduate next year.
I will support you.
The body's fatal injury
was made with the green meat skewer.
The dead person
was Ou Xiaodi.
She wanted to take revenge for the brother.
At 10PM 3 of December.
That was the body that we used.
Right.
I'm sorry.
Can't blame you.
You also destroyed my brother's face.
No,she thought I did it.
She saw me burying that dump of trash
so she thought I was
the murder of body destroying case.
Right?
Because my little brother
is a distinguished student
majoring in environmental protection.
He's the pride of my family.
In M city,
my relationship with my brother was really good.
He got to my house everyday
waiting for me to finish work.
But that day,
he sent me a message,
saying he was going back to the dorm
and not waiting for me.
I went to the bathroom
through the back yard,
taking a short cut through the back flower garden back school.
When I arrived home,
I wanted to call him to ask if he was back to school yet.
I called him then found out that
his phone is ringing upstairs.
I thought he hadn't bring his phone with him.
I wanted to head for the back yard
to follow him and give him the phone.
But when I got to the back yard, I saw
my brother was lying with his face down
in the hole.
When I lifted him up,
I saw this skewer stabbed into his chest
and he was dead.
I ran for help.
When I came back with a person who could help
my brother's body was nowhere to be found.
I'm so sorry.
So I didn't tell the police.
You didn't tell the police but investigated yourself.
That's right.
I was wondering
why there were so many holes.
I waited there for so long.
I was always ambushing
to see who did that.
Then I saw He
often going there to bury things in the holes.
I'm sure that my brother
accidentally fall into the hole
then died when stabbed by the skewer.
So whose skewer is it?
Who dug these holes?
They're stills big questions for me.
Then I found out that these holes were dug by you.
Whose skewer
is it?
It is Zhen's.
Because I found out that he was having a BBQ on the terrace.
I took one to see
then it appeared to be the same as the one that stabbed my brother.
And you take this.
That's right.
It means you wanted to kill
both of them?
Right.
There's a mobile phone.
It's locked. We need the password.
There's a tablet
in Ou Maiga's room.
There's confidential documents that are not opened.
Where's the computer?
The computer's here.
Computer.
Let's see.
Let's have a look.
The first one is in the confidential document
which hasn't been opened.
Phone number? Is it the phone number?
I'll try with the ending numbers
8795.
We got it.
It opens.
Consumers' forum.
This is the addictive
that I've found in the restroom recently.
What is it?
After buying MG company, Processing Department said
Hello my darling, I saw the photos you took
about MG draining and MG detoxifying liquid.
When these two types combine with other things in the bathroom
will turn into cloudy white
and release toxicant.
According to experimental findings,
in an area of 15 square meters closed room,
a drop of MG draining liquid level five,
dissolving in 500 milliliters bleach.
will create poisons
and within 20 minutes
can make an adult dead.
When people breath in these poisons,
they will foam at the mouth.
Please notice to open an air vent before going to the toilet.
She found this information.
So, you know that
after 20 minutes from the time breathing in these toxic gases, people will die?
Now we have to find the password of the laptop.
Pass
Maybe it can be related to this information.
ID
omggmo
Is it right?
It's open!
What is the meaning of this beautiful photo?
No.
This is the photo of the plan to eliminate people,
of the first and second victim's photos.
This is her source of photos.
Look at it.
They're the same.
It was her who made this video.
It proves that you created the next
the next targeted people?
Right.
What's your plan?
I wanted to kill He through Zhen
so I made this photo
to imply with Zhen that
He wanted to kill you and you would be the next victim.
and I would be the next victim after you.
Therefore, he would feel nervous the most
and spring out the idea to kill He.
So cruel.
She posted a detailed plan
on an oven
and told everybody that
somebody had sent it to her.
It means that
it was you who knew all about the upcoming plans.
I knew that
because I started it first.
It was me who
bought incense sticks
for him.
I also told him the plan for murder.
But I never participated in
any actions that killed other people.
So
her level of suspicion will be reduced.
She definitely prepared a plan
to talk
with Zhen.
He wanted Zhen to use that plan and kill you.
Right.
But why did Zhen turn out to be a victim?
Before he could kill you,
somebody had known this plan
and used it to kill Zhen.
I have a feeling that we still lack an evidence.
Let's continue to find.
I'm coming.
I really like finding things.
Faint when being sprayed on.
He was made fainted by the murder.
What's this?
This was certainly the paper that he used.
Was it used to soak the narcotic?
No.
After the victim fainted,
the murder would continue to use the paper that was soaked with narcotic
because the victim still breath after fainting.
When using this method, the victim would die within 20 minutes.
After the victim fainted, the murder would stage the crime scene
and run.
The murder wore a mask to get out the scene,
and arrange things to close the door.
The victim inside
would die after 20 minutes.
Is there anything else?
Are there other things?
Lift it up.
Here. There's a clue. Hurry up.
A string.
A lighter and a string.
Durable nilon string.
Durable, no friction, no elasticity.
The weakness is prone to catch fire.
It will be cut off when exposing to sparks.
It will burn when exposing to fire.
Let's try to see whether it's easy to catch fire or not.
What if the sting will be cut as soon as we burn it?
Don't put your hands on.
Don't hold it. Take your hands away.
It's truly easy to catch fire.
No sooner had we burned than it was cut off.
So the murder could
use the string to hold it.
Take the string there to try.
Take it there.
Did murder really do like that?
There's a nail here.
A nail?
Where?
Here.
There's a nail above here.
A string.
What's this?
The string was burned.
The string was tied to a brick.
The weight of the brick
would block the door.
Was this the way that made the door unable to open?
But how
did he burn the incense sticks to ignite the string?
When the incense stick burned a half,
it would rupture the string and open the door.
Everybody notices that
whether
the string was tied to the door handle?
Maybe there is a piece of string left.
It may like the string over there.
Let's turn over the victim to check.
Let's see.
Turn him over. We're sorry.
Here.
Oh, here it is.
What?The string.
What are you?
There're fingerprints on the door handle.
Right.
So the string was tied here?
The murder led the string out.
How did the murder burn the string?
From out of window.
The murder jumped out, right?
No.
It's not fine to do that.
It's OK.
But this is the wall.
I know that this is the wall.
But the murder could threw the string out firstly.
Used the brick.
Right.
Used the brick to throw the string out of the window.
The murder tied the string to the brick and threw it out.
The murder did that.
Stand here.
come.
Throw like this.
So the murder might use the brick to hammer the nail into the wall
and tie it.
But before the murder took place,
The victim had fainted.
Right.
Who had met the victim here
would know the time the victim was here.
Somebody saw
the dating message.
Somebody saw that paper.
Somebody saw. Moreover, after reading it, he burned it.
Who knows this plan?
Ou knows. This is Ou's plan.
I know.
I'm sorry, but you only know briefly about this plan.
You don't know its details.
I didn't see.
At least,
we didn't read that plan.
What about Gui? Don't you know anything?
Let's use clues we're having
to re-enact the crime scene.
What do you think?
Starting from Ou,
She created an imaginary scenario.
She put 2 photos
into the hole that you dug.
Then she told Zhen that
He wanted to kill you.
So Zhen sprung out the ideas to kill He.
Simultaneously, she made a plan to help Zhen.
She wanted to kill He through Zhen.
Right.
Ok.
We'll start from here.
You made a plan
and gave it to Zhen
but Zhen didn't want to
become the criminal.
So he found me and third brother
to make us kill He for him.
Right.
He used that evidence to threat us.
Right.
but like what we had said,
we didn't read the details of this plan.
The plan wasn't conducted,
but you prepared this plan, didn't you?
Tell everybody what the plan was.
Right,
that is my plan.
Have you found it? Where?
At the window.
There's a phone inside.
He's had a cosmetic surgery.
What?
Beauty salon Zhen Piao.
This place again?
He's Jia Erer. He's my younger brother.
Are you second brother?
Are you my older brother?
You're second bro Jia.
Is it the game of relatives' reunion again?
Brother.
Where did you go?
The stage now should be named "It is as if there weren't any separations"
Brother, where did you go?
Why did you change your face into scarred one?
Why did you call it a scarred one?
I adjusted like
a unique face in 4000 years of "Handsome He".
I took a lot of surgeries,
but they could clear my scar
so my face turned out to be like this.
Why did you take cosmetic surgery? What happened?
I became a target of mafia.
The reason why did you disappear is
Actually
when I called you here,
my life was still fine.
I couldn't expect that the treatment had some accidents.
But when I was come after,
you started to come here.
So I didn't have any ways but hide you.
I thought I just needed to hide in one year.
I couldn't imagine that they still came after me.
So I thought if I came back,
not only me but also you
could be at risk.
Therefore, I decided to change my face like another person.
But I still worried about you,
so I changed my identity
into Scarred He.
I've been always by your side.
I wanted to quietly
take care of my older brother,
my younger brother and sister.
It's so touching.
Unexpectedly, then I discovered that
Zhen Baoxian
found out a person
who had a scar on his leg.
It means that your motive
is not related to clues
that were found in the rubbish bin?
My mistake was that I threw it into the rubbish bin.
You dug a hole.
I'm kind of a violent person.
You only dug a hole, right?
I'm a bad guy
but my purpose was to protect myself
and my brother and sister.
because I couldn't let them know I was here.
These are all evidences showing that He threat other people.
I had to keep Zhen's Baoxian mouth shut.
Second brother,
in the future if you take another surgery,
please watch"Who's The Murderer?".
That beauty salon Zhen Piao is not reliable.
There's a noticeable scar on your face.
Not accounting this scar,
I feel quite satisfied of all.
Now the problem is that
the incense stick burned through in 20 minutes
and the victim also fainted in 20 minutes.
It means that
if the victim died at 7:35,
it would be about 7:15 ...
No, listen to me.
If the victim fainted,
20 minutes was enough
to make him dead.
What about the incense stick?
If the murder wanted to burn the incense stick,
he had to come back at 7:15.
Because when we came to the scene, the incense stick had burned a half.
So it must have been 7:15
when the murder burned it.
But at 7:15,
everyone was staying at the same place.
Four of us was having a meal.
All the evidences direct to Ou.
So Ou is the murder.
But I think everything is not simple like that.
Maybe the murder used another way
to burn the stick.
I showed up at 6 a.m this morning.
She dropped in to give me some things at 6 a.m this morning.
Everybody went out before 7 a.m?
I think
from 6:30 a.m to 7 a.m,
no one has a alibi.
It proves that the victim's estimated time of death
was certainly from 6:30 a.m to 7 a.m.
The murder used another way
to burn the incense stick at 7:15
or he used another way to make the incense stick burn slowly.
What about combining two incense sticks together?
If he had done that, it would leave the trace.
There're definitely clues left.
Check the flower bed.
There's a bunch of incense sticks.
The sandalwood.
Refined sandalwood.
10 sticks in a bunch.
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8
9 sticks
9 sticks, it lost one stick. Sorry everyone.
It proves that the murder used the incense sticks here.
Excellent young man, count them again.
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8
It lost 2 sticks.
9
Is this incense stick
longer than the one before?
This stick is double in its length.
It will take more time to burn through.
Sasa, this incense stick is longer.
I told you.
High five.
You're so intelligent.
This stick was certainly used to buy time.
The burning time
is not 20 mintues
It's 40 minutes.
It burned in 40 ...
"Trouble"
The incense stick "troubled" in 40 minutes. (In Chinese, the word "trouble" and "burn" are pronounced almost the same)
The incense stick would through in 40 minutes. It mean that there was 20 minutes left.
So the murder burned the incense stick at 6:55.
and then came back to have a breakfast.
This clue proves that
the murder deliberately made the alibi.
Somebody found out Ou's plan.
Right.
The murder took advantage of
this
to buy longer incense sticks
Right.
When he did that,
everyone would think that he used the shorter one.
The murder can say that
he couldn't do that in 20 minutes.
Let's interrogate one by one.
I'm coming.
Interrogating round.
The detective has the right to interrogate each suspect.
Do you have anything to say?
Now, there are 3 types.
One is me and Guigui.
Both of us don't know anything about the murder plan
but have the motive to commit a crime.
The second is Ou.
She not only has the motive to commit a crime but also knows about the plan.
There is one more thing which is the two brothers.
Sa and Liu
Both of them have chance of knowing about this plan.
They also know where the plan could be hidden.
However, both of them said that they didn't see it.
Obviously, they wanted to "kill" this person
but they said they didn't do anything.
So I think I should concentrate on
finding out the gap in their speech.
So I'm more towards the hypothesis
that Sa saw this plan
then burned it.
Today Sa is quite weird,
he seems to have no vitality.
Right, today he seems not to focus at all.
Do you find out that
there are many things he was like
"it was irrelevant to me, irrelevant to me at all"?
I find that Liu always takes investigation seriously.
But it's always Liu's style.
He is a youth with full of energy,
he is really energetic.
Right.
Anyway, now I primarily keep track on
Sa and Liu.
Guigui.
Gui doesn't look like a "murderer" at all.
If the murderer was Gui,
today she played really well.
So how about you?
Actually, I...
the most passive point of me is that...
Because
actually I
do have motive to "kill" him.
Because I want to protect my family members and myself.
But the only thing
I can say to justify myself
is that I needn't kill someone.
Because he hasn't known that I'm Jia Erer.
He doesn't know
because he still tells the other that
he says "after making everything clear
then I'll tell you".
He is still investigating me.
But you know that he wants to "kill" you.
I don't know that he wants to "kill" me.
Which point shows that he wants to "kill" me?
How can I know that he wants to "kill" me?
Done.
Who is the next to call in?
Call Ou
Ou , call Ou right?
Ou.
Okay.
There is food.
I found out his mobile phone.
You've just scared me that I almost "die".
Since when have you been here?
I've just found out the mobile phone of "the victim".
I don't get it well.
Long gangster
Have you taken a shot of the scar yet?
I want to compare a bit.
I haven't taken a shot of it yet
but the scar is really identical to
the picture which you gave me.
Anyway this face is not the person who I want to look for.
There is no additional evidence
I can't believe you,
don't deceive me.
Okay, so this Long gangster
didn't believe that he found out He.
Zhen did call Jia Dasa and Jia Sanliu.
These are two different phone numbers, right?
Yes.
Ou Mmaiga, the detective is waiting for you.
Okay.
Hello, detective.
Hello.
Who are you suspecting?
My analysis now is,
because I, Sa and Liu,
are three people who have most direct motives to "kill" the victim.
But why Gui doesn't have any
imperative motive to "kill" someone like that?
Also Gui just said that
"I just want to protect my elder brother
so I want to kill him".
However, it's not definitely Gui who "killed" him.
The most urgent person must be
Liu and Sa.
At 10 o'clock, they will have to hand in a million
for their sister to cure her brain illness.
Right.
Right?
Now it's close to 7, 8 o'clock.
That means today he has to "die".
If he doesn't "die",
then this a million will not be taken away.
So they are the most urgent people.
Right.
There is a problem that
the key is that the murderer had used your plan.
So I eliminate you.
I find that you may not be the murderer.
But there is a question about
who saw this plan,
knew this plan
and fixed your plan.
Moreover, this drug is at whose place,
who has possibility to use this kind of drug.
The person who saw the plan
probably prepared this thing.
When did you tell this plan to Zhen?
At 3:00 p.m on 12th day.
3:00 p.m.
I bought incense for him.
Incense had been burned for 40 minutes.
So the time of "murdering" was before 7 o'clock.
Why did he go to the toilet before 7 o'clock?
Drugged him
then pulled him into the toilet.
The first place where the case happened was not here.
That means he was dragged away,
then was drugged and "died" here.
There were two people who did go out.
Sa went out in the early morning.
Gui did go out.
Let's call Gui in.
Call Gui in.
Okay.
Who are you suspecting?
Ou.
Why?
She just based on bamboo stick and the trap
then guessed that
this person "killed" that person,
which seems a bit forced.
Okay.
The next thing
It's such a lack of respecting for suspect.
I do respect you.
Really.
So tell me
do you think that there is anything strange?
Do you suspect big brother and third brother?
My brain doesn't feel good, I don't want to talk to you anymore.
No
Now do you suspect any other things?
Big brother is weird, too.
Really weird, right?
I feel that second brother is still good.
The big brother had plastic surgery.
Okay, who do you want to call in?
You asked me then can you find out the answer?
I did gain a lot.
Did I help with anything?
It's the happiness.
We feel happy.
Okay, who do you want to call in?
Sa.
Okay.
Master Sa, you finally come.
Who are you suspecting now?
The current situation is like that
the main point is definitely finding out
who knew the plan.
Right.
Ou had created this plan
then she told it to Zhen.
Zhen knew it.
Zhen wrote down this plan
then put it above the BBQ.
The BBQ is the public space,
everyone can see it.
But who was the person who took it away to burn after seeing it?
About this information,
there was only Zhen who called to told me and Saner
If two of us did it,
why did Zhen appear
in the toilet?
Zhen called two of us,
that means he wanted to use us to "murder".
Which means that he didn't need to "kill" someone himself,
just needed to let us do.
Earlier, we did analyze.
He surely fainted away in his room first,
then was dragged to the toilet.
Zhen lives in the farthest corner from the toilet.
If he was dragged from his room to the toilet,
his body must have passed everybody's doors,
which is really dangerous.
I personally suppose that
Zhen definitely ran into the toilet by himself.
But why is that?
But he obviously knew that it's 7:00 according to the plan.
how could he run into the toilet earlier?
He came there to check?
It might be that at 7:00, he had to come there to supervise
if this work had been done or not.
This could happen.
His purpose when letting you do this thing
is to tell others that you are the ones who did it.
"This thing is irrelevant to me".
So at 7:00 he...
at 7:00 he must have gone to have breakfast,
at 7:00 he should go
to the place that was crowded.
He wouldn't wait at a deserted place.
Please help me to think who this person is.
So who is the person has possibility
to have a date on the next early morning?
Moreover, the point is that the paper was burned.
I also feel that there is a possibility
this person is Ou.
Because Ou knew the whole plan.
If Ou is "the murderer",
so she is extremely brilliant.
Firstly, she had to know that you guys
definitely went to eat at 7:00.
After that she meant to use the incense
to rewrite it was 40 minutes,
then added 20 minutes more.
Then she did all of these things,
then pushed all responsibilities for you.
It doesn't really make sense.
Okay, call Jia Sanliu in.
This time he is really serious.
I feel that it's quite fake.
Hello
two detectives.
You're the last person I call in,
do you know why?
Because I'm excellent.
Right, because I totally believe you,
the murderer is you, right?
No, it's not.
Who do you think the murderer is?
I come here to present the whole of this case for you.
Now I incredibly want to hear your presentation.
Do you need paper and pen?
Master.
There are some points that you definitely have to doubt about,
that is "murdering" plan.
Everyone except for Ou,
all is capable
after receiving these 2 calls,
which is after 5:00 p.m the day before yesterday,
then we can know the answer.
About the thing that this paper was burned into ashes,
this thing...
There are only two of you who know.
Right, unless now two of you surely suppose that
between me and Jia Dasa,
one of us is "the murderer".,
this person is definitely not me.
I find that at the moment
the real suspect is
one of us, right?
Now do you find out any better ideas?
If it just simply considers the motive for "murdering"
to make a guess,
then the person who I suspect most
actually is He.
But now I find that
I haven't found out
any intact thing which is considered
as a direct evidence.
You said that considering the motive for "murdering",
why He is the most suspected person?
Because actually he has nothing to be rushed.
He was kinda urgent too.
What is the thing that Long gangster is chasing to "murder"?
The most urgent people are you and Sa.
I really suspect a point
no matter adding more time to burn incense
or whatever,
actually to blame this crime
"on the head" of other person.
Now in contrast, I find that the possible reason might be
that the incense was longer.
If no one is discovered,
then the most suspicious is Ou.
Because no one knows,
everybody all suppose that the time for burning incense was short.
If the time for burning incense was short, Ou would not be on the scene.
I find that the motive for "murdering" of Xiao Gui
is not strong.
Considering based on current clues,
Xiao Gui originally doesn't have any motive for "murdering" at all.
Why didn't I receive this paper?
The reason is that I feel
using the way of "murdering" which Zhen knew
to "kill" Zhen
is too foolish.
So my story and Sa's are totally the same.
They are really the same.
Unless there is one of us who tells lie.
Okay.
Everyone repeats about your timeline for a bit,
let's begin from Sa.
I woke up at 4:30
then went out to teach Bai to play basketball.
At 6:30
I came back to my basketball shop.
30 minutes later
I stayed in the basketball shop to deliberate
how to kill Zhen.
Because I knew that
there was a person who had already had the plan.
I couldn't use this plan to kill him.
I could just make another plan.
Could you make it?
But I couldn't think of anything.
At 7:00, I went downstairs to have breakfast,
with my younger brother and younger sister.
Going downstairs to have breakfast at 7:00
is your habit?
Right.
At the restaurant we had breakfast,
we met Scarred He.
So having breakfast at 7:00 is really important.
This timeline proves that they weren't on the scene.
Hey detective, can I ask you
to let me say first?
Okay.
Because I want to rearrange former timeline.
Because I want to
let him "kill" He for me.
I and Zhen Baoxian had definitely always been in touch.
On 12th day,
I appointed to meet him in the toilet,
and talked to him about the "murdering" plan in closed room.
I told him that
He would come home at 7 a.m on 13th day.
This was the best time to do it.
But at 5:13 p.m,
he sent me a message.
A moment ago, I had a call
and He was beside me.
It really scared me.
I wondered that who was this calling for?
Calling for us.
I find that this message is
relevant to the thing that you knew the content of this call.
as well as overheard the content of this call
You recorded it like that.
We were in a call
so He did know.
I didn't hear anything of it
I just knew that he was finding me.
I was afraid that he knew I was Jia Erer
I want to ask older brother and younger brother for a bit.
Using his younger brother to pretend that it was my body
was done by you two
right?
Yes.
I want to ask you a question.
When you two received a threatening call,
did you discuss with each other?
No, we didn't.
Why?
Both of you did
the same surprising things.
Why didn't you talk to the other,
didn't choose to act,
didn't look at the plan as well?
There was someone who did something
without telling his elder brother or younger brother?
The more people this plan is relevant to,
the more people to be blamed.
The more people in the family to be blamed
You see, between them,
each of them does want to protect the other.
Like this,
now I do suspect you
I believe that you do suspect me, too.
Actually, I don't suspect you.
I really don't suspect you.
My younger brother
makes me feel so touching.
Can you please coorperate with me for a bit?
We'll use this way
to eliminate my suspect on you,
is it okay?
Okay.
If our stories
are really the same
including after receiving the call,
the methods and our plans
are not different.
Now let's look at each other's eyes.
We are back to the mental status after receiving the call
to say it out.
Okay, let's do it.
Say at the same time.
Say at the same time to see if they are coincident or not.
How about palpating?
We'll palpate.
Okay okay.
Okay.
Okay, let's start, palpate,
3 2 1
After receiving the call I found that
I didn't know
if he and He had any kind of enmity.
Right
I didn't need to "kill" an innocent person
because of this thing.
Right.
Moreover, I felt that after "killing" him,
it might be...
after he knew this thing,
he was able to control me.
I didn't know what else could he threatens?
So obviously, I
couldn't use this plan to "kill" him.
I had to make another thorough substitute plan.
So the next day, before I had to buy insurance,
I had to find the way to "kill" him.
Okay.
Via eyes contact, I eliminate my younger brother.
I'll ask another question
Why
Someone wanted to swap the incense stick.
I'm thinking of this logic,
the "murderer" swapped a longer incense stick
for what reason?
It's because from 7:00 to 7:30,
those eating breakfast downstairs can tell that who didn't appear at the crime scene.
The reason for swapping the short stick with a longer one is
to put the blame on someone else between 7:00 and 7:30,
the one who wasn't downstairs.
That person is Ou.
We, the three brothers,
always have breakfast at exactly 7:00 everyday.
Yeah.
So he wanted to put the blame on Ou,
and eliminate three of us.
I feel that your name should not been San Liu.
should be Yiliu.
I think it's He.
If your way of thinking is true,
then it's not He, either.
Because he is always watching us,
he is protecting us.
He must know that
three of us have breakfast at 7 o'clock.
Push all the suspicion on Ou.
Wrong.
I want to ask if it was me,
then how could I guess that
she wouldn't come down for breakfast at 7 o'clock?
Because she doesn't eat breakfast.
Can I control whether she eats or not today?
You can't.
There's no indication that
Ou wouldn't come down for breakfast at 7 o'clock.
The "murderer" could only make sure that
he was eating there at that time.
The "murderer" had no way to
protect anyone or blame anyone.
Because he couldn't control
who came down to eat at 7.
He could only control that he would be eating there at 7,
ensure his own safety.
Because you're the second brother,
you know that, at 7 every day,
they have breakfast.
But I don't know that
you told him to "kill" me at 7.
If I really wanted to protect myself
and protect my family,
then I would use a different method to "kill" him.
I couldn't let
any potential danger remain.
Because I didn't know who was my partner.
I feel that the current problems are:
Firstly, the burned piece of paper,
why is it in the "victim's" room?
Secondly, why did the "victim" run into
the restroom?
He clearly was looking for the person helping him kill someone.
These are still unclear.
He had that burned piece,
then he must have known that
someone wanted to help him "kill" someone.
The "murderer" definitely had contacted Zhen.
He also had a method to lure him out.
He had a way to ask him to come outside,
or he somehow must have known that Zhen
would fall for that trap.
I just want to ask who had the chance
to meet Zhen like that.
You think that this person
could meet Zhen before 7 in the restroom,
then there must be two people
having the same intention,
or some kind of plan.
But what is the plan?
It must be on the paper.
How did the "murderer" dare
meet Zhen before 7 o'clock?
It's because he had this 1-hour incense stick.
So he had enough
time to prove that he was not at the crime scene.
He told him
"I can meet you before 7 o'clock.
Because first of all, I want to help you "kill" that person,
but after 7 o'clock, tell me
what I need to do."
The phone was only used by those two,
he was not afraid of meeting Zhen.
After burning the paper,
he went to talk to him.
Someone must be lying.
Let's vote.
Today's case,
the one I suspect the least is Ou Maiga.
Because her timeline
helps her a lot.
So among the rest,
my siblings,
I feel it's unlikely that Xiao Gui is the culprit.
Today, from her state,
she really doesn't know anything.
So there are only my older brother,
and my younger brother.
I feel that my brothers
are identical.
After the other gives an order, they do nothing.
Besides, their reasons are also the same.
So finally, who is it
that needed to "kill" Zhen Baoxian so urgently?
So today I choose...
After eliminating in all aspects,
the one I suspect the most
is still He Daoba.
Firstly, he is our second brother,
he has
a protective desire
towards the three of us.
Secondly, he has a motive for "killing" Zhen,
a strong one.
Because he found out that Zhen Baoxian
had been investigating him.
If he wants to save himself,
then he must "kill"
Zhen Baoxian.
Moreover, I always believe that he
had accidentally heard
the "murder" plan that
Zhen Baoxian told us.
So I feel that this can be
the most direct motive for "murdering".
I also feel that it's
the most urgent.
So I'll vote for He Daoba.
Today, I
have no clue.
What they were talking about,
I don't really get it either.
Anyway, I'm not the "murderer".
Ou Maiga, a big yes.
He Daoba,
a little bit.
Jia Dasa,
yes.
Jia Sanliu,
no.
Jia Xiaogui,
basically no.
Then I'll choose...
This person kept looking at me and saying,
you're suspicious too,
it's you who are truly suspicious.
Open the door.
Thank you.
According to our last clues,
I feel that the most suspicious person today,
it's probably this one.
Believe my instinct.
So we don't have the most important evidence.
He has the timeline.
He went outside.
So he had more time
to commit the "crime".
Losers are always in the wrong.
Because I chose Sa in the first round,
so if he is the one, you will have two correct votes.
Yeah, or else I won't even get one.
From the beginning to the end, I feel that my third brother,
his logic is very good.
Why did the "murderer" have to
swap the short stick for a longer one?
He wanted people to think that
the time frame of the "crime" is only 20 minutes,
but in reality, it's 40 minutes.
So how did this benefit the "murderer"?
Firstly, he could take advantage
of that time frame.
Secondly,
he directed people to focus on
this 20-minute time frame.
So you can immediately rule out
those who were eating breakfast.
So don't forget that among those who eat breakfast downstairs,
aside from me who comes down every day,
San Liu and Xiao Gui
this morning there's also He Daoba.
I still believe in the answer in front of me
which the logical thinking and evidences gave us.
I hope that
my answer is correct.
Such a
bad feeling.
Let's see who will be the one receiving that song today.
The one who kept lying.
I'm telling you,
this is the first time I actively sing that song.
No clue at all.
Today, I have to see who will this song
be given to?
When we find out the "murderer" later,
no matter who,
whether they are captured or not,
let's surround that person and sing this.
Alright.
Weave, weave, weave a flower basket.
I will teach you, there's a dance, too.
Ready, go.
Weave, weave, weave a flower basket.
Weave...
Everyone, I with you, you with me,
woven into a flower basket.
You have never played this when you were young?
Never.
Please, let's announce the answer first.
Please announce.
"Who Is The Murderer", the 5th season, the 5th case.
In "The crime on the rooftop",,
who is the "murderer" that "killed"
Zhen Baoxian?
Who is it?
Firstly, I will announce
the safe player who receive 0 vote.
It must be me.
You're that confident?
If it's not, I will go down on my knees..
I will kowtow to you.
Jia Xiaogui.
It's over.
Where do you guys get so much confidence?
There's still another player who received 0 vote.
One more, Ou.
That person is
Jia Sanliu.
Congratulations to the two players who are temporarily unsuspected.
There are still people who voted for us?
Did you vote for me?
I didn't.
Xiao Gui, come on.
I didn't.
Weave, weave, weave a flower basket.
No, who voted for me?
Now I'll announce the player who received 1 vote.
Is this for real?
That person is
Ou Maiga.
I want to bite this cage.
Between the two remaining players,
He Daoba,
Jia Dasa.
I feel that he is very suspicious today,
because
today this person had listened to that phone call.
This person, to protect this family,
had done this by his own hands.
I feel that the most suspicious person today,
it's probably this one.
The two players received
the same number of votes.
The same?
Only Jia Xiaogui
didn't vote for them.
It's you who are truly suspicious.
That's right.
Why did you vote for me?
So what are we going to do now?
So now, Jia Xiaogui will decide
who will go into the cage?
Come on, put this pot on your head.
Why me?
Xiao Gui.
Hold your two blood brothers' hands tightly.
You can do this, I tell you,
this is the only way.
I will open the cage for you.
What are you doing, Xiao Gui?
Why are you doing this to me?
Doctor, she needs surgery immediately.
Her condition is getting worse.
Xiao Gui.
You are holding your two brothers,
the only brother you can trust
is standing behind you.
That brother standing behind her,
you're the only one she can trust right now.
Because no matter what we say...
Like this, Xiao Gui,
tell the two of them to compliment you,
who gives the best compliment,
you won't vote for him.
My compliments to you now will be lies.
All lies.
I can't lie.
Is this for real?
Gui.
You have to make the most important decision
in your life.
Why is this the most important decision
in her life?
Because she has made so many mistakes.
You can't keep making mistakes over and over again.
If you arrest me,
the next 5 seconds
will be the 5 seconds you regret the most in your life.
You tell me that every time.
Trust me this time.
I hope you'll trust me this time.
I don't want to.
Look into my eyes,
I hope you'll trust me this time.
Or you can let them say a few things
first.
It's not me.
Hao Ran,
you're the only one that can help her
make a sound judgment.
We have the same story.
You could be lying.
But we were talking at the same time,
how could I lie?
I didn't know what he wanted to say.
You could have learned it by heart.
I could only learn mine,
I couldn't learn his at the same time.
Doctor, please perform surgery on her.
There's no judgment.
Because this, I,
basically, I didn't understand what you were saying.
Then you should at least understand what I've just said.
Don't let yourself have that most regretful 5 seconds.
An immediate 5-second.
Jia Xiaogui, please give the final decision.
Him.
Come in here.
Jia Dasa,
please get in the cage.
She urgently needs surgery.
Seriously, it's urgent.
Come on, lock it.
Lock your big brother in.
In the cold night, longing turns into a river.
I believe you're the "murderer".
It's fine if you're not.
She just wants to lock you in.
Life is a bunch of constant regrets.
So in the end, is Jia Dasa
the "murderer"
who "killed" Zhen Baoxian?
The legendary detective gadget,
OPPO Reno3 Pro.
It's time to reveal the "murderer".
Now, I'll announce,
your accusation
is wrong.
Sorry.
Big brother, I'm sorry.
Quickly do your surgery.
The detective's assistant please brings the award.
I have prize but lose the world,
how can I do?
How it can be you?
I had to fake the evidence not on the scene,
there was a key clue
on the window's curtain,
it was a ticket.
It said that at 5:45,
I left the clinic.
I lied that I left at 6.
But I found the final receipt,
He bought joss sticks, a lighter
and a rope.
They're inside the waste sorting bins.
Sandalwood - super product,
anesthesia spray,
durable rope,
a lighter and an anti-poison mask.
December 12.
Who bought these things?
It's very simple,
I knocked on his house's door.
Once he saw me, I sprayed anesthesia
and dragged him to the bathroom,
that was simple.
I bought everything
for the plan.
There was no one preparing beforehand.
How could you see the note on top?
I listened that call.
In fact,
I feel that
there's a reason
that I'm standing here.
What I did with the third brother,
whatever it meant
I should be locked.
We could count as successfully scamming insurance money.
Though we couldn't get the money,
getting no money
is an objective reason,
which led to the end of our "scamming".
Not because we subjectively gave up,
we haven't done "scamming insurance money".
Today we used a corpse
which didn't have receiver.
It meant that
we destroyed a family's hope.
We did this as the first time,
it's hard to guarantee that
next time when we need money,
can we really "kill" someone?
Because we used this "corpse"
it was considered as evil,
which could be covered forever,
there's no way to find the truth.
That's why I feel
sorry to Ou.
Please remember
if you save a person
don't hurt someone else.
Nice talk.
When everyone does that,
or else it will become a great loss.
Until the final action,
it felt like my brother "died" unplanned
That's why I feel
waste sorting
is an important thing.
Everybody does something
as a small deal that won't affect others.
Gathering them all can become a murder.
Right.
Nice talk.
Doctor,
doctor.
After a tense discussion,
let's bring in a happy introduction.
Shaking when finding out details in the case,
stable recording thanks to Reno.
Many thanks to Oppo Reno3 Pro,
which has 5G technology and video-recording,
sponsors this show.
DouYin - The more you play, the higher you'll be, it can't be wrong when solving a case,
thank you for recording the best moment in life,
sponsored this show.
Turn it,
lick it,
dip it,
Super Oreo
has all the steps.
Thank you Oreo for a delicious treat, happily play,
which sponsors this show.
Is Pepsi there?
Thank you the delicacy,
all have Pepsi to solve the case,
sponsors this show.
Thank you Pepsi.
Finding the truth,
finding that you're better,
Thank you Bosch - science achievement, life's beauty
which sponsors this show.
Cleansing water that sweeps all dirt,
cleans the skin and brings back beauty. Cleansing water that sweeps all dirt,
cleans the skin and brings back beauty.
Thank you, the cleansing water
with micellar technology, L'OREAL
sponsors this show.
Thank you.
Let's meet in the next case.
Thank you everyone.
Thank you for your hard work.
Thank you.
Going to South Mountain to plait the flowers.
Plaitng...
I plait...
Everyday, people
are producing a huge amount of waste,
creating waste.
It's "killing" the Earth slowly,
"killing" ourselves.
For example, sea turtles,
mean that we will eat, won't treat them properly.
Throwing garbage into the sea
is a coincidence.
If you don't do that,
there won't be a coincidence.
It's easy that everyday,
spending 10 minutes,
we can sort the waste.
It's about people's habit.
If we are good at waste sorting,
at least we can reduce
the ability to hurt others.
In a long term,
it will reduce many troubles in the future.
You don't need to ask
why we need to sort the waste.
It's about our lives.
After waste-sorting is done,
a good life really starts.
Protecting the environment isn't something small.
What we often say is
don't think that we should do small evil things and shouldn't do small good things.
Each person
spends a bit more time.
We can all change the earth's future.
Protecting the nature.
I feel that
this is what people should do.
A small contribution.
2016.
Don't do it, don't die.
In this cold weather,
the fire is back.
Why you try?
YCYU
first performance on stage.
Want to dance on sisters' eyelashes.
I'm in charge of high notes and producing songs
in YCYU.
I'm very talented.
You can't question about my music knowledge.
That's right.
Wu - big sister.
I'm 22 years old,
how could I be big sister?
Sis, are you doing well?
You're not old.
Step a side.
I'm Xiao Yao in the crew.
I'm sorry,
I'm the type who can eat a lot
but not gain weight...
Tell it,
don't let me see you.
I'm Rapper Bai,
used to be the hottest guy in the world.
Recently, I've done weightlifting,
so they call me weigh-lifting Bai.
Sorry,
after doing gym,
many people fall in love with my body.
So...
Look at your small mouth when being resentful.
I thought that I was selected.
Liar.
I'm the rapper
that MG company just signed a contract.
There's no way.
Some people were dismissed.
It's like "First love is a big deal",
"Winter has come"
and "To our freezing time".
I bet everyone watched them.
We don't need these.
What else,
I maintain the reality.
I want to be myself.
It's getting hot.
Big sister, Rong.
Senior, we don't like what you're saying,
I don't care if you listen or not.
You're so young.
These flowers are for you.
Flower.
Wei Xiao brother, best things are for you.
Don't you dare use your trick.
Hey, bring it to my room.
He Shanzai.
Handsome Ha.
I will never forget.
What MG entertainment trained...
trained me.
Actually it was him.
Right.
Give me your hands, quickly.
Forever with you.
We'll never be separated.
Something happened, quickly come here.
December 20, 2016.
"Victim" is 22 years old.
Zhen Wanmei.
When she was perfoming,
suddenly seized,
and then fell.
"A star was born" cast,
after finishing shooting,
there were 3 actors in the movie
were killed.
Sister,
brother,
father
were all in there.
The movie detail...
It's not different
from what he just said.
The person that "series murderer" killed in the movie
final murdered
was the character that Zhen Wan Mei played.
There's a person behind all four cases.
Dissociative identity.
Handsome He came to the scene.
It's you who killed Xiao Hua.
He Handsome, you disappointed me.
Why is this bag in your room?
How do you know this?
Why did you "kill" her?
No, I didn't.
"Killing" them
is dissociative identity.
I'm not sure.
Why are you being like this?
Is it dangerous
to you?
At worst, we can destroy.
Thank you Oppo R17 Pro
a brand new taking photos phone,
sponsored this show.
After reading, he's full of sweat.
Thank you.
Stable recording.
What is stable recording?
Shaking when fining out details in the case,
stable recording with Reno.
Wait a minute,
when he's shaking,
the video is recorded stably.
Because he used a mobile phone
which has video stabilization,
Oppo Reno 2